Jump to content

Father biondi - vote of no confidence


3Bill

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 244
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

+ 1

Frankly, I think some of youse guys ought to stick to basketball, cuz this is way more complicated than you realize...

And I know I'll get hammered by the usual suspects as some sort of socialist or worse... but professors are not the bad guys in this scenario. They (and I) are just sick and tired of being sick and tired of the same old same old--despite all the warm and colorful flowers and trees being planted every year.

I've been a good boy for a pretty long time on this board, so it's difficult to know where to begin, or what to say. . . .but for starters, as one person mentioned: you might want to read and think about the contents of the 16-page letter delivered by the Faculty Senate to the Board, for a lengthy listing of very serious mistakes/ and at times unethical actions by the present administration. these are rather serious and yet all I keep hearing about are the wonderful grounds and buildings, and how bad midtown used to be.

I love the campus, but I suggest you go visit Florence. the churches and buildings there are also sublime. but they are empty on Sunday mornings, pretty much. splendid buildings do not a church make; and neither do splendid campuses. I'll just repeat what another person said: the faculty IS the university; not the nice flowers and great basketball stadium (which I like a lot, by the way). Maybe that's how it works at a major bank, or a Fortune 500 company (the "real world," as someone will now say): autocratic, vindictive iron-fisted rule behind closed doors; fear and loathing haunting the halls and stairwells; very real stories of colleagues being made to suffer for disagreeing or airing out grievances; colleagues from all over the country calling us or emailing us and asking, "What the hell is going on at SLU??" -- but I've given some of the best years of my life to SLU, and I can tell you the crisis is very real; and I and other faculty are deserving of some (genuine) part of the decision making process, and many, many things done under the "SLU Mission Statement" premise are simply wrong. Believe me, when students wax eloquent about their memories of SLU and the people who "changed their lives,' well, it generally isn't the administrators they mention (Chaifetz aside).

And I get tired of good natured and intelligent alumni--like on here-- not seeming to understand any of that. so think back: who changed your life at SLU (if anyone): was it a (marginalized and underpaid) faculty member?

OK, hammer away....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

For someone that is so much in favor of a good representative of the university, I can't believe you don't want Biondi gone. From the stories I have heard of him, his actions don't represent the SLU community very well at all, especially for a priest.

biondi has accomplished a hell of a lot more good than bad. saint louis university is what it is because of father biondi.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Frankly, I think some of youse guys ought to stick to basketball, cuz this is way more complicated than you realize...

And I know I'll get hammered by the usual suspects as some sort of socialist or worse... but professors are not the bad guys in this scenario. They (and I) are just sick and tired of being sick and tired of the same old same old--despite all the warm and colorful flowers and trees being planted every year.

I've been a good boy for a pretty long time on this board, so it's difficult to know where to begin, or what to say. . . .but for starters, as one person mentioned: you might want to read and think about the contents of the 16-page letter delivered by the Faculty Senate to the Board, for a lengthy listing of very serious mistakes/ and at times unethical actions by the present administration. these are rather serious and yet all I keep hearing about are the wonderful grounds and buildings, and how bad midtown used to be.

I love the campus, but I suggest you go visit Florence. the churches and buildings there are also sublime. but they are empty on Sunday mornings, pretty much. splendid buildings do not a church make; and neither do splendid campuses. I'll just repeat what another person said: the faculty IS the university; not the nice flowers and great basketball stadium (which I like a lot, by the way). Maybe that's how it works at a major bank, or a Fortune 500 company (the "real world," as someone will now say): autocratic, vindictive iron-fisted rule behind closed doors; fear and loathing haunting the halls and stairwells; very real stories of colleagues being made to suffer for disagreeing or airing out grievances; colleagues from all over the country calling us or emailing us and asking, "What the hell is going on at SLU??" -- but I've given some of the best years of my life to SLU, and I can tell you the crisis is very real; and I and other faculty are deserving of some (genuine) part of the decision making process, and many, many things done under the "SLU Mission Statement" premise are simply wrong. Believe me, when students wax eloquent about their memories of SLU and the people who "changed their lives,' well, it generally isn't the administrators they mention (Chaifetz aside).

And I get tired of good natured and intelligent alumni--like on here-- not seeming to understand any of that. so think back: who changed your life at SLU (if anyone): was it a (marginalized and underpaid) faculty member?

OK, hammer away....

i think if you believe that the teachers cant be replaced both in quantity and quality you are naive. i do agree that the majority of the teachers are likely stellar educators. but that can be said at most universities. the university is not the teachers alone. it is a combination of everything and the party(ies) responsible for coordinating all is the reason saint louis university is what it is.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 months later...

Don't believe everything you read in the paper on this. There are some people who have their own agendas...and they are not currently helping the University, its students, alumni or other stakeholders.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What are you talking about? Do nothing until 2012? Fr. Biondi sure deserves his share of criticism but to marginalize 25 years of his true accomplishments and then to state that "any reasonable" administrator would have done the same is just plain wrong. Most administrators keep the status quo. Fr. Biondi has done the complete opposite.

+1

Biondi is polarzing, but by no means ineffective.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

drama....

- The Theology Dept Chair resigns as chair and now the tenured faculty refuse to fill the position...

- The A&S Faculty Council said that Faculty Senate Vice President Jane Turner “reported hostile environment” from the Board of Directors. But Dr. Turner herself "played down the affair in an email, saying she would not characterize trustees’ reaction as hostile."

This is after Faculty Senate President said in an interview with the Post Dispatch: "We all need to move on.”

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is the mass email Hammond (Theo Dept Chair) sent out:

The Chair of the Department of Theological Studies, Professor Jay Hammond, has resigned in protest over Fr. Biondi's ongoing leadership of this university, and the Board of Trustees' failure in its 11 February 2013 communication to address the no confidence votes against the president of Saint Louis University. Attached is his explanation for his decision.


The tenured faculty of the Department of Theological Studies met on 19 February 2013, and in a unanimous vote, declined to fill the chair's position in solidarity with him, and in support of his reasons for resigning. The faculty statement is also attached here.

Attachments:

http://www.scribd.com/doc/126666364/Hammond-Explanation-of-Resignation-021913

http://www.scribd.com/doc/126666367/Response-of-Department-of-Theological-Studies-Tenured-Faculty-021913

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had Hammond for my capstone and he is PHENOMENAL. This lends a huge amount of credibility to the faculty's opinion. Biondi needs to get us into the conference and then gtfo

i disagree... i got an A in Hammond's class, but he surprised me with an 'AF' (attendance failure) right before christmas break. i didn't really care, but still... who cares about attendance??????????

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i disagree... i got an A in Hammond's class, but he surprised me with an 'AF' (attendance failure) right before christmas break. i didn't really care, but still... who cares about attendance??????????

This is why you dont think. He is a great professor? I do have to admit that I never missed that or many other classes, so I did not get an AF.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had Hammond for my capstone and he is PHENOMENAL. This lends a huge amount of credibility to the faculty's opinion. Biondi needs to get us into the conference and then gtfo

I had Hammond when he was a first-year prof for a theology requirement called "The Matrix and Religion." It was a summer class so about 35 students enrolled thinking all we would do is get high, watch the Matrix trilogy and talk about Jesus. Well, there was about eight required texts and six 10-page papers over the length of the course.

At the end of the summer, there were five people left... we took the blue pill. He was an incredibly challenging and demanding professor and other than Dr. Thomas Shippey over in A&S, had the driest sense of humor on campus. You either meshed well with him or you GTFO of that class.

Hammond was, without a doubt, the best lay theology professor I've ever had.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


×
×
  • Create New...