WUH Posted April 5 Posted April 5 15 minutes ago, Lord Elrond said: I thought the new rule was a hard limit of 15, including all scholarships and walk ons in that limit? I thought the purpose was to prevent teams from loading up with players. Or am I mistaken? Or, is it like everything else the past few years, just a court case away from completely changing? A limit of 15 including walk-ons, yes, for schools that opt-in to the settlement. Quote
HoosierPal Posted April 5 Posted April 5 37 minutes ago, Lord Elrond said: I thought the new rule was a hard limit of 15, including all scholarships and walk ons in that limit? I thought the purpose was to prevent teams from loading up with players. Or am I mistaken? Or, is it like everything else the past few years, just a court case away from completely changing? Just think of it as 15 jerseys. That’s all you can have on the bench/roster. Lord Elrond 1 Quote
brianstl Posted April 5 Posted April 5 52 minutes ago, Lord Elrond said: I thought the new rule was a hard limit of 15, including all scholarships and walk ons in that limit? I thought the purpose was to prevent teams from loading up with players. Or am I mistaken? Or, is it like everything else the past few years, just a court case away from completely changing? I saw today that a challenge was recently filed against the proposed 15 man roster limit because it is an illegal restraint of trade. At least I think that was the reason. I will try to find where I saw it. Quote
billikenfan05 Posted April 5 Posted April 5 50 minutes ago, brianstl said: I saw today that a challenge was recently filed against the proposed 15 man roster limit because it is an illegal restraint of trade. At least I think that was the reason. I will try to find where I saw it. I for one am SHOCKED Quote
BrettJollyComedyHour Posted April 5 Posted April 5 10 hours ago, brianstl said: I saw today that a challenge was recently filed against the proposed 15 man roster limit because it is an illegal restraint of trade. At least I think that was the reason. I will try to find where I saw it. Lol, restraint of trade. What a world. Quote
slu72 Posted April 5 Posted April 5 14 hours ago, brianstl said: I saw today that a challenge was recently filed against the proposed 15 man roster limit because it is an illegal restraint of trade. At least I think that was the reason. I will try to find where I saw it. So wouldn’t that affect just about every biz in America, ie those who run businesses cannot determine the size of their workforce? Quote
HoosierPal Posted April 5 Posted April 5 4 minutes ago, slu72 said: So wouldn’t that affect just about every biz in America, ie those who run businesses cannot determine the size of their workforce? All professional sports have roster limits. Why shouldn’t professional college sports have roster limits? 3star_recruit 1 Quote
okay Posted April 5 Posted April 5 Wonder what will happen to the walkons when we reach the 15 player limit. I assume they might be used for practice still, just not officially on the team Quote
brianstl Posted April 5 Posted April 5 1 hour ago, HoosierPal said: All professional sports have roster limits. Why shouldn’t professional college sports have roster limits? Professional leagues have collective bargaining agreements with actual employees. thatskablamo 1 Quote
cheeseman Posted April 5 Posted April 5 1 hour ago, slu72 said: So wouldn’t that affect just about every biz in America, ie those who run businesses cannot determine the size of their workforce? Business do not set arbitrary work force sizes. They determine what the company needs and it can fluctuate with each business being different. Quote
HoosierPal Posted April 5 Posted April 5 33 minutes ago, okay said: Wonder what will happen to the walkons when we reach the 15 player limit. I assume they might be used for practice still, just not officially on the team You have 15 game jerseys to hand out. Quote
Dr. Holly Hills Posted April 5 Posted April 5 Try that at your next board of directors meeting.. “we only have 15 jerseys fellas…” Quote
brianstl Posted April 6 Posted April 6 23 hours ago, brianstl said: I saw today that a challenge was recently filed against the proposed 15 man roster limit because it is an illegal restraint of trade. At least I think that was the reason. I will try to find where I saw it. It was actually that enforcing the limit amounts to an illegal cartel agreements. https://x.com/therealshenger/status/1907091925116801287?s=46&t=6urbQRIhStGl70a4QUhnHA Quote
Aquinas Posted April 6 Posted April 6 I put together a summary description of the players and position projections of the players currently committed to the 2025 Billikens: 12 of the 15 scholarships. For the last 3 scholarships: 1 We need a center as the only player over 6’8”, other than Robbie is freshman Max Kerr. 2 We need a ball handler. Right now, our ball handlers are Amari McCottry and Trey Green. Green has a high ceiling, but has played limited minutes and had mysterious health issue last year and only played in the first 9 games. 3 Schertz Wild Card – last year’s wild card was Dylan Warlick, who made significant contributions. Centers: Robbie Avila 6’10”240 Jr, Center, 33.9 Min, 17.3 Pts, 6.9 RB, 3Pt% 35.9, FT% 75 Power Forwards: Paul Otieno 6’8” 225, Sr Forward, 31.1 Min, 10.4 Pts, 8.6 RB, 37.5 3Pt%, FT% 81.1 from Quinnipiac Kalu Anya 6’8” 215, JR, Forward, 27.9 Min, 6.5 Pts, 7.5 RB, 3Pt% 125, FT% 31.6 Wings: Quentin Jones 6’5” 170, Jr, Guard, 33.6 Min, 13.1 Pts, 4.8 RB, 3 Pt% 35.5, FT% 76.6 from Northern Ill. Dylan Warlick 6’5” 210, FR, Small Forward, 10.1 Min, 2.4 Pts, 1.6 RB, 3P% 38.5 FT% 75 Kellen Thames 6’6” 21, SO, Guard, 16.3 Min, 6.2 Pts, 3.4 RB, 3 Pt% 30, FT% 62 - Big Health question. Can also play a small power forward. Shooting Guards:0 Dion Brown 6’3” 180, Sr Guard, 25.6 Min, 7.5 Pts, 3.9 RB, 3 Pt% 35, FT% 75.7 from Boston College. Point Guards: Amari McCottry 6’6” 215, FR, Guard Wing, 14.5 Min, 4.6 Pts, 3.1 RB, 3pt% 38.5 FT% 58.7. Can play any guard position or small power forward in a pinch. Trey Green 6’0” 168, Jr, Guard, 13 Min, .5.5 Pts, 1RB, 3 Pt% 33, FT% 96.3 from Xavier . Only played 9 games beginning of last year. Had undefined health issue. Ranked about 70 out of high school. Stats from combined first 2 years. He is a gable with very high ceiling. Freshman: All 3 have reputations as outside shooters. Hutson might be the closest to div 1 play. Max might be needed as we only have 1 player over 6’8” at this moment. Jax Ker 6'11' 190, 247 4 star recruit from Oklahoma last summer averaged 11.0 points, 5.0 rebounds and 1.8 blocks. He shot better than 40 percent from the arc Cameron Hutson 6’6” 190 , 247 3*, 18.9 Pts, 7.2 RB, 45% 3pt Luke Laczkowski 6’7” 200, 247 3*, 21.5 Pts, 8.5 RB, 2000 points for his high school. Considers himself shooting guard. Nickname Lach. Couldn’t find percentages. CK-85 and TheA_Bomb 2 Quote
davidnark Posted April 7 Posted April 7 22 hours ago, brianstl said: It was actually that enforcing the limit amounts to an illegal cartel agreements. https://x.com/therealshenger/status/1907091925116801287?s=46&t=6urbQRIhStGl70a4QUhnHA It's all the same legal theory--horizontal restraint of trade/illegal cartels are all prohibited under Section 1 of the Sherman Act, which is the primary antitrust law in the US. Individual businesses can set whatever employee numbers they want, but it is illegal for competing businesses to agree upon a limit together. Effectively, the D1 colleges are competing businesses. If the players form a collective bargaining unit and agree upon a limit with the NCAA/schools, it is no longer an illegal restraint of trade. This is why major sports leagues legally have roster rules and salary caps. Quote
wgstl Posted April 7 Posted April 7 1 hour ago, Aquinas said: I put together a summary description of the players and position projections of the players currently committed to the 2025 Billikens: 12 of the 15 scholarships. For the last 3 scholarships: 1 We need a center as the only player over 6’8”, other than Robbie is freshman Max Kerr. 2 We need a ball handler. Right now, our ball handlers are Amari McCottry and Trey Green. Green has a high ceiling, but has played limited minutes and had mysterious health issue last year and only played in the first 9 games. 3 Schertz Wild Card – last year’s wild card was Dylan Warlick, who made significant contributions. Centers: Robbie Avila 6’10”240 Jr, Center, 33.9 Min, 17.3 Pts, 6.9 RB, 3Pt% 35.9, FT% 75 Power Forwards: Paul Otieno 6’8” 225, Sr Forward, 31.1 Min, 10.4 Pts, 8.6 RB, 37.5 3Pt%, FT% 81.1 from Quinnipiac Kalu Anya 6’8” 215, JR, Forward, 27.9 Min, 6.5 Pts, 7.5 RB, 3Pt% 125, FT% 31.6 Wings: Quentin Jones 6’5” 170, Jr, Guard, 33.6 Min, 13.1 Pts, 4.8 RB, 3 Pt% 35.5, FT% 76.6 from Northern Ill. Dylan Warlick 6’5” 210, FR, Small Forward, 10.1 Min, 2.4 Pts, 1.6 RB, 3P% 38.5 FT% 75 Kellen Thames 6’6” 21, SO, Guard, 16.3 Min, 6.2 Pts, 3.4 RB, 3 Pt% 30, FT% 62 - Big Health question. Can also play a small power forward. Shooting Guards:0 Dion Brown 6’3” 180, Sr Guard, 25.6 Min, 7.5 Pts, 3.9 RB, 3 Pt% 35, FT% 75.7 from Boston College. Point Guards: Amari McCottry 6’6” 215, FR, Guard Wing, 14.5 Min, 4.6 Pts, 3.1 RB, 3pt% 38.5 FT% 58.7. Can play any guard position or small power forward in a pinch. Trey Green 6’0” 168, Jr, Guard, 13 Min, .5.5 Pts, 1RB, 3 Pt% 33, FT% 96.3 from Xavier . Only played 9 games beginning of last year. Had undefined health issue. Ranked about 70 out of high school. Stats from combined first 2 years. He is a gable with very high ceiling. Freshman: All 3 have reputations as outside shooters. Hutson might be the closest to div 1 play. Max might be needed as we only have 1 player over 6’8” at this moment. Jax Ker 6'11' 190, 247 4 star recruit from Oklahoma last summer averaged 11.0 points, 5.0 rebounds and 1.8 blocks. He shot better than 40 percent from the arc Cameron Hutson 6’6” 190 , 247 3*, 18.9 Pts, 7.2 RB, 45% 3pt Luke Laczkowski 6’7” 200, 247 3*, 21.5 Pts, 8.5 RB, 2000 points for his high school. Considers himself shooting guard. Nickname Lach. Couldn’t find percentages. Agree Hutson is likely the most ready coming in, but I’d say Luke is right there also. Jax is very much like Robbie other than body type, you can see why the staff wanted him. Hes a center who gets the other 4 heavily involved. my biggest need is a knock down 3 point threat. Quote
Aquinas Posted April 7 Posted April 7 31 minutes ago, wgstl said: Agree Hutson is likely the most ready coming in, but I’d say Luke is right there also. Jax is very much like Robbie other than body type, you can see why the staff wanted him. Hes a center who gets the other 4 heavily involved. my biggest need is a knock down 3 point threat. I couldn't find much video of Luke. He did an i terrier after the high school season where he described himself as 6'7". The little video made him look like a spot up 3 it shooter. Stats show him as 21 pt per game, so he must alsi have insude game. . He also played tennis, so he must have decent quickness and body control. I just don't have a sense of his readiness in terms of speed and strength. My overall exptations of this group of freshmen is that they will hit open 3s, when they get a chance to play. Quote
HoosierPal Posted April 10 Posted April 10 @studurando · 1h With the dead period ending tomorrow, SLU will have several players from the portal on campus in the next week. The focus is still on guards with playmaking, shooting skills, speed, defensive versatility. https://x.com/studurando/status/1910342523601514848 billikenbill 1 Quote
wgstl Posted April 10 Posted April 10 I kinda want Kerr to play a decent amount with Robbie being a senior. Its risky for sure. CenHudDude 1 Quote
HoosierPal Posted April 11 Posted April 11 Read this mornings Stu on SLU. Schertz doesn't intend to use all 15 scholarship. Quote
billikenfan05 Posted April 11 Posted April 11 15 hours ago, wgstl said: I kinda want Kerr to play a decent amount with Robbie being a senior. Its risky for sure. Kerr not backing up Robbie would be extremely disappointing. I don't know how many minutes, but Robbie doesn't need to be playing 40 minutes. Quote
wgstl Posted April 11 Posted April 11 4 hours ago, billikenfan05 said: Kerr not backing up Robbie would be extremely disappointing. I don't know how many minutes, but Robbie doesn't need to be playing 40 minutes. you gotta get Kerrs feet a little wet, even if its 5mpg. Perhaps even something like Robbie 30, Paul 5, Kerr 5 Quote
WUH Posted April 11 Posted April 11 6 hours ago, HoosierPal said: Read this mornings Stu on SLU. Schertz doesn't intend to use all 15 scholarship. Interesting. Does he want to keep open the option of picking up a mid-year transfer if one comes available, I wonder... Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.